First Published: 2007-12-10

Reply: The Un-American Way of Torture

In 1776, many Americans believed in generosity to prisoners. George Washington encouraged kind treatment for Hessian prisoners, writes Brian O’Malley.


Middle East Online

Dear Editor,

In her October 9, 2007 column, The Un-American Way of Torture, Mona Eltahawy wrote of attending an anti-torture protest in America. A passerby apparently referring to detainees at Guantanamo Bay said, “So maybe we should send them all picnic baskets and flowers, then.”

In 1776, many Americans believed in generosity to prisoners. On December 25, 1776, George Washington captured several hundred Hessian mercenaries garrisoned at Trenton, New Jersey. In his book, The Day is Ours, William M. Dwyer quoted from Herbert H. Freund's translation of a journal by Johannes Reuber, one of the Hessians captured on Christmas Night at Trenton.

As the prisoners approached Philadelphia, a curious crowd gathered to view the Hessians. Some charitable souls even brought food and drink for the prisoners. A vengeful chorus, however, soon agitated the crowd: “They cried out that we ought to be hanged for coming to American to rob them of their freedom.”

The hecklers shoved aside magnanimous gift-bearers and transformed the curious crowd into an angry mob. The American guards had to rush the Hessians to safety.

Reuber added, “Later, General Washington of the Americans made a proclamation and it was posted all over the city: the Hessians were without blame and had been forced into this war. The Hessians had not come of their own free will. They should not be regarded as enemies but as friends of the American people and should be treated as such.”

According to Reuber, the change was instantaneous. “Because General Washington had full authority and he gave his honest word, it became better for us. All day long, Americans big and little, rich and poor, came to the barracks and brought us food and treated us with kindness and humanity.”

In the book Enemy Views, Bruce E. Burgoyne offered this translation of Reuber: “Old, young, rich and poor, all treated us in a friendly manner and each day we received one pound of bread and meat....”

In both translations, however, George Washington encouraged kind treatment for Hessian prisoners.

With regards,

Brian O’Malley

Atlantic Beach, Florida

United States of America


Iraqi Kurds may postpone referendum in return for concessions

Assad says no Syria ties for countries backing rebels

Rouhani says top priority is protecting nuclear deal from US

Iraqi-Arab Gulf rapprochement makes headway

In Egypt, Syrian refugees recreate Syria

In African tour, Sisi seeks to rebuild ties, address security and water concerns

Syria’s transition scenarios for future rounds of talks

Dubai real estate market sets the pace for renewed growth in the GCC

German-Turkish intellectual held at Ankara’s request

Jordan’s municipal elections marred by deaths, riots

Russia doubts IS claim of stabbing attack in northern city

Turkey slams 'arrogant' German reaction to Erdogan poll call

Police confirm Finland 'terror attack'

Spain hunts suspects as IS claims attack

Aid project helps Syria refugees feel at home in Jordan

Lebanese army launches anti-IS offensive on Syria border

UN demands access to Yemen ports

Low-cost attacks a new reality for Europeans

Forces of Libya's Haftar say commander wanted by ICC in detention

Yemen rebels urged to free political commentator

Iranian footballer breaks silence over ban for playing Israelis

Erdogan meddles in German politics

IS fighters almost encircled in Syrian desert

For Israel, White House ties trump neo-Nazis and antisemitism

Israel freezes implementation of settlement law

Saudi Arabia installing cranes at Yemen ports

13 dead, 100 injured in two Spanish seaside city attacks

Iran reform leader ends hunger strike

Van ploughs through pedestrians in Barcelona terror attack

13 killed in Barcelona van attack

Iraq acknowledges abuses in Mosul campaign

Netanyahu under fire for response to US neo-Nazism

Israel to free high-profile suspects in money laundering probe

Spanish police shut down jet-ski migrant smugglers

Syrian actress, activist Fadwa Suleiman dies in Paris

Israeli court extends detention for Islamic cleric over ‘incitement’

UAE to provide $15 million a month to Gaza

Sudan's Bashir 'satisfied' with Nile dam project

US-backed rebels say American presence in Syria to last ‘decades’

Tunisian clerics oppose equal inheritance rights for women

Israel strikes almost 100 Hezbollah arms convoys in 5 years

UN hopes for eighth round of Syria talks before year’s end

LONG READ: How Syria continues to evade chemical weapons justice

Civilians killed in US-led raids on Raqa

Qatari pilgrims begin flooding into Saudi by land