First Published: 2012-07-19

 

Russia-China veto shatters Western hopes to tighten noose on Assad

 

Third veto opens up acrimonious battle at Security Council over who is to blame for failure to get international action to halt Syria conflict.

 

Middle East Online

By Tim Witcher - UNITED NATIONS

US: We will now act outside of UN body

Russia and China on Thursday vetoed a UN Security Council resolution that would threaten sanctions against Syria's President Bashar al-Assad if he does not end the use of heavy weapons.

The third Russia-China veto in nine months opened up an acrimonious battle at the 15-nation council over who is to blame for the world powers' failure to get international action to halt the Syria conflict.

There were 11 votes in favor, with Russia and China voting against and with Pakistan and South Africa abstaining. As two of the five permanent members of the council, Russia or China can veto any resolution.

Amid growing doubts over the future of the peace mission of UN-Arab League envoy Kofi Annan, the United States said it would now act outside of the UN body to confront Assad. Russia said the West wanted "military intervention".

"We will intensify our work with a diverse range of partners outside the Security Council to bring pressure to bear on the Assad regime and to deliver assistance to those in need," US ambassador Susan Rice said.

"The Security Council has failed utterly in its most important task on the agenda this year," she added, while warning of reports that Assad's government could use chemical weapons in the battle against the opposition.

"The United Kingdom is appalled at the veto of Russia and China," said Britain's UN envoy Mark Lyall Grant, whose country -- another permanent council member -- took the lead in writing the resolution.

"The effect of their actions is to protect a brutal regime. They have chosen to put their national interests ahead of the lives of millions of Syrians," Lyall Grant told the council.

"It is clear that Russia only aims to give more time to the Syrian regime to crush the opposition," said France's envoy Gerard Araud.

"Refusing Annan the means of pressure that he asked for is to threaten his mission," Araud told the Council.

The British text, backed by the United States, France, Germany and Portugal, threatened non-military sanctions under Chapter VII of the UN Charter if Assad does not withdraw heavy weapons from Syrian cities in 10 days.

However the sanctions were only a threat and would have needed a new resolution, western envoys stressed.

Russia accused Western nations of seeking to use the proposed resolution to justify military intervention in Syria.

The resolution sought to "open the path to the pressure of sanctions and further to external military involvement in Syrian domestic affairs," Russia's UN ambassador Vitaly Churkin said after his veto.

Churkin said the West had sought to "fan the flames of extremists, including terrorist groups."

China's ambassador Li Baodong said Western nations had been "arrogant and rigid" in negotiations on the resolution.

The sanctions proposal was added to a resolution on renewing the UN Supervision Mission in Syria (UNSMIS) whose 90-day mandate ends on Friday.

Without a resolution, the UN may have to hurriedly withdraw the nearly 300 unarmed observers now in Damascus.

The UNSMIS operation has been suspended since June 16 because of the mounting violence.

Russia had said it could not accept sanctions or action under Chapter VII.

It drew up a counter-resolution which would just renew the UNSMIS mandate but withdrew the text because it became clear that it could not get the nine votes needed to pass.

The five Western countries along with Colombia and Morocco had indicated they would abstain on the Russia text, assuring its failure.

India's ambassador Hardeep Singh Puri said it was "regrettable" that the council had not sent a united message to the Syrian leadership to back Annan. He said council powers had acted on their "national interests".

Pakistan, which abstained, said that urgent action must be taken to make sure UNSMIS stays in Syria.

More than 17,000 people have been killed since an uprising against Assad began 16 months ago, activists say. The Security Council faces growing criticism over its failure to take action.

UN chief Ban Ki-moon and international envoy Annan had called on the Council to unite and take strong action on Syria in the hours ahead of the vote.

Ban said there was an "extreme urgency" for action to make government and opposition forces halt the violence. Annan said the council must take "decisive" action on the conflict.


Name see gul
Country USA
Russia and China have only guaranteed more killing by the Assad regime but not its survival. At this point Assad can only continue to kill. He has no control over any matters of the government other than the military and that is rapidly dimenishing. What has Russia and China accomplished? Nothing except more brutality and the guarantee that they will have no future positive relations with Syria.
 

Khamenei’s tailored election: Rafsanjani and Mashaie barred from presidential race

Bouteflika’s heath condition: Another Algerian state secret?

Egypt gears up for possible rescue operation with large security sweep

Qusayr battle reveals widening scope of proxy war in Syria

Dubai successfully foils smuggling of 259 African ivory tusks

‘Crucifixion’ of Yemenis in Jizan: Everything old is new again in Saudi Arabia

UAE court readies verdict in secret organization case

Saudi nabs 10 more Iran spy suspects

Syrian attack on Israeli patrol: Accounts contrast

Tunisia radical Islamists engage in trial of strength with Ennahda

Deadly SARS-like virus reaches Tunisia

Blood of Iraqi Ambassador sanctioned in Jordan

Massive tornado: Obama declares major disaster in Oklahoma

US rings alarm bell over rising tide of religious intolerance

First sea turtle nest spotted at Saadiyat Beach

Iran wants to take part in Syria peace conference

IMF predicts Saudi economic slowdown

US criticises Egypt's civil rights record

Battle for Qusayr: Hezbollah sends new elite fighters

Kerry visits Oman for mega defense deal, Mideast talks

Bouteflika’s absence paralyses Algeria politics

Iran’s Guardians Council hints Rafsanjani not fit for presidency

Mauritania's ruling party: Abdel Aziz will not step down

Israel ‘fabricates’ its innocence from murder of Mohammed al-Dura

Maliki’s remedy for Iraq sectarian violence: Overhaul of security strategy

Qatar emir laments international failure over Syria

Egypt sends reinforcements to Sinai as speculation grows

Spokesman’s surrender to Mauritania deals another blow to Ansar Dine

Another ‘Bou Azizi’ in Saudi Arabia: Street vendor dies after self-immolation

Rising storm of violence hits Iraq hard in May

Bahrain court slaps nine Shiites with jail terms over 'terrorist' cell

Abu Iyadh to Tunisia rulers: Thank you tyrants, but we will never be defeated!

US drone strikes again in Yemen

15 killed in string of bomb attacks in Iraq

Battle for Qusayr: 23 Hezbollah fighters killed

Militants set their sights on mosques in Iraq

One dead in police clashes with Islamists in Tunis

UAE calls for political action to stop 'repressive Damascus’

Egypt's Morsi rejects negotiations with Sinai kidnappers

Tough measures against expatriates raise concerns in Kuwait

Maliki chooses ‘cosmetic solution’ for Iraq sectarian wounds

Clashes in Tunisia as Ansar al-Sharia clings to escalation

Strategic city of Qusayr falls into hands of Assad forces

Internet enters ‘coma’ ahead of Iran presidential election

Saudi Arabia vies to dissuade its nationals from joining ‘jihad’ in Syria