First Published: 2017-09-26

Nation as a Fortress: We Will All Be North Korea By Another Name
In a world of fortress nations, with severely circumscribed interests and mindsets, collective defence is a paradox and selflessness a sin, explains Rashmee Roshan Lall.
Middle East Online

In 1945, when the Soviets installed Kim Il-sung as putative head of the new country called North Korea, the former guerrilla presented himself to his people as a leader who would build up the nation as a fortress. North Korea would be racially pure and therefore superior to the mixed-race Muggles in South Korea and everywhere else. It would be impenetrable to imperialists, mostly because foreign entry would be restricted.

Now, 72 years later, and the idea of fortress nations seems to have become alarmingly popular in unexpected parts of the world. Consider the following:

US President Donald Trump’s senior aides want an annual cap on refugee entry of 15,000, which is approximately half the world’s daily number of new refugees. Trump has until October 1 to decide on the issue.

Leaked reports suggest the White House is being selective in its information-gathering process. It is said to have rejected an official study that said refugees earned the government billions more in revenues over the past decade than they cost. It is obvious that refugees have been added to an anti-immigrant agenda that is meant to secure the fortress nation.

Anti-immigrant parties are gaining support in Germany, which voted September 24; in Austria, which votes in October; and in Italy, which votes early next year. Only in Austria is there a real chance that rising hostility to foreigners, especially those from the Arab world, will propel the anti-migrant party into government. The conservative Austrian People’s Party, which shifted closer to the far-right Freedom Party’s positions on immigration and Islam, has maintained a poll lead in the four months since the election was called.

Finally, countries are defending their walled fortresses by any means possible. Extraordinary new deals are being done. Italy may be paying Libyan warlords to prevent migrants from setting sail in the central Mediterranean, the busiest route into Europe. The European Union is paying people traffickers in Niger to start other businesses, which don’t involve the dispatch of human beings.

The Italians deny a monetary arrangement with the warlords but it’s hard to understand why else the number of migrant arrivals from Libya would fall sharply the past two months. In July, arrivals in Italy were down 50%; in August, 85%.

If money is changing hands, it shouldn’t really be particularly shocking. Eighteen months ago, the European Union as a whole brokered a money-for-migrants deal with Turkey. Ankara was promised more than $7 billion to help pay for the upkeep of migrants intercepted on the Aegean Sea route to Europe.

That arrangement seems to have worked even though Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is routinely caustic about it. He complained to the UN General Assembly that Europe was stumping up less than it should.

In a way, Erdogan’s constant grousing pairs well with Trump’s eternal griping. Both seem to believe that a sharp-eyed, elbows-out and hostile world is taking advantage of their countries. However, their narrow self-focus merely illustrates the philosophy Trump has proposed as the guiding principle of global affairs.

He told the General Assembly that sovereignty should reign supreme rather than submission to global collectivism. Refugees, by extension, were cast in terms of a hopefully short-term affliction that is best quarantined in or near the refugees’ home countries.

“Are we still patriots?” the US president asked world leaders at the most multilateral institution on Earth. “Do we love our nations enough to protect their sovereignty and to take ownership of their futures?”

In real terms, that was a call to base nationalism, a nod to me-first transactional relationships rather than inspirational or aspirational shared values.

In a world of fortress nations, with severely circumscribed interests and mindsets, collective defence is a paradox and selflessness a sin.

We will all be North Korea by another name.

Rashmee Roshan Lall is a regular columnist for The Arab Weekly. She blogs at and is on Twitter @rashmeerl

Copyright ©2017 The Arab Weekly


Iraq takes control of two key Kirkuk oil fields

New UN envoy in Rabat to restart talks on WSahara

Hollande slams Trump's hardline stance on Iran nuclear deal

Mogadishu twin bomb death toll at 276

Lebanon promotes ‘back to public school’ drive

Netanyahu presses Russian defence minister on Iran

US-backed forces retake Raqa state hospital

Divided Iraq tests limited US influence

Iraqi forces seize Kirkuk governor's office

Iraqi forces seize airport, oil field from Kurds

Saudi Arabia sets conditions to role in Syria reconstruction

In tougher approach, US offers multimillion-dollar reward for Hezbollah operatives

EU ministers join forces in support of Iran deal

Batteries, tape to thank for defeating jihadists in Raqa

Palestinian Authority top official visits Gaza

Israel strikes Syrian anti-aircraft battery in response to shots

Qatar starts to feel pinch from sanctions

Last days of Raqa battles ‘toughest fighting yet’

Omani role has helped Iran but may not do much in crisis with US

Head of IS in Southeast Asia dead

Gazans hope Palestinian reconciliation ends their woes

US-backed forces announce ‘final phase’ of Raqa recapture

Suspicion of football corruption shows limits of Qatar’s ‘soft power’

Schools closed on first day of term in rebel-held Yemen

Iraqi forces in standoff with Kurds in oil-rich Kirkuk

Protests in southern Morocco over water shortages

Iran’s Zarif says Trump speech in violation of nuclear deal

In Egypt, illiteracy rates down but problem remains

ISIS regroups in Libya amid jihadist infighting

Egypt’s Nation’s Future Party seeks to build on youth vote

Qatar freezes assets of royal member over Gulf crisis

Morocco dismantles IS-linked terror cell

Syrian troops recapture city of Mayadeen from IS

Gulf countries voice support for Trump’s tough stance on Iran

Princess named to head Saudi sports federation

IS fighters surrender as defeat in Raqa nears

Former French culture minister picked to head UNESCO

Baghdad issues ultimatum to Kurds on Kirkuk

Trump tears into Iran, leaves nuclear deal hanging

Iranians respond with anger, mockery to Trump speech

Somalia's defense minister, army chief resign

EU says it must watch IS in North Africa 'very carefully'

NATO chief urges US, Turkey to 'find solutions' to row

Turkey deploys troops to Syria's rebel-held Idlib

Four jihadists killed in Mali