First Published: 2017-10-12

Monetising Grief: Humanitarian Television in Refugee Settlements
By stripping away the context, the perilous journey refugees embarked on to reach the camps is discounted, writes Nazli Tarzi.
Middle East Online

Tales of wartime survival and exile have typically been communicated by displaced individuals who lived to tell their tale. We have read their memoirs, listened to their stories and watched their journey to safety broadcast live.

With the emergence of satellite television and new media, refugees, it seems, are no longer guardians of their story or message. The scenes of horror many fled have inspired a broad range of responses and television corporations recognise these prickly subjects are too large to ignore.

Because it is not possible to deny the commercial value of television news shows addressing the refugee crisis, we can question their morality. Do they educate, challenge, defy misconceptions about refugees or normalise the permanent state of homelessness for these populations?

These are the questions that coursed through my mind upon watching the second series of the BBC Insider, which takes viewers on a journey to Iraqs largest refugee camp in Dohuk, Domiz, as told by presenter Reggie Yates.

The chosen format is a curious one. The host enters the camp and undergoes the same vetting procedures as refugees. With nothing but a rucksack and the clothes on his back, Yates arrives into the UN-run encampment as though he was displaced by conflict. He then trudges through a barren terrain in a staged replay of a small part of the painful journey walked by every refugee.

The documentary cannot be critiqued for what it says but for what it does not say. Abundantly clear throughout the 50-minute feature is that no in-depth analysis of how the refugees came to be in Domiz was intended. By stripping away the context, the perilous journey refugees embarked upon to reach the camp is discounted.

Beyond the emergence of the Islamic State (ISIS) in Syria, the audience was told little about the peoples uprising and the bloody crackdown unleashed by Syrian tyrant Bashar Assad. Viewers were also told virtually nothing about Iraqs 3 million internally displaced people.

Another dangerous assumption that moves steadily throughout is that little is changeable. The positive image of the camp and the UN handiwork teaches audiences that life churns on in these quasi-cities and the economy, as Yates describes, is thriving.

As we know, however, this is no land of milk and honey.

Less apparent to viewers are the absence of diverse voices and the mono-ethnic make-up of camp residents. There is a brief history of the camp and the numbers it was built to accommodate but not much about whom the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) of Iraq accepts to host. The overwhelming majority of refugees who are featured speak Kurdish. With surgical attention to detail, viewers can also catch glimpses of KRG President Masoud Barzanis portrait sneaking on screen.

As informative as it appears, the documentary monetises grief, even if to deliver messages that garner much-needed attention while skimming over important facts. The BBC is not alone. Other broadcasters have rushed to enlist celebrities to shine the stage light on refugees while denying them the microphone.

The privileged status celebrities have is what provides the access to a space no person has settled into wittingly. If this approach encourages positive images and participation in humanitarian efforts, no harm can be done but, lest we forget, the primary purpose of these shows is to entertain. Education comes second to that.

The existence of the camps is a phenomenon necessary to explore but humanitarian reality television may not be the answer.

The lasting damage is when programmers design shows that abandon the promise of change, when the populations themselves refuse to let up.

Nazli Tarzi is an independent journalist, whose writings and films focus on Iraqs ancient history and contemporary political scene.

Copyright 2017 The Arab Weekly


Sarkozy says life ‘living hell’ since corruption allegations

Hezbollah leader says debt threatens Lebanon disaster

Turkey’s largest media group to be sold to Erdogan ally

Rebels to evacuate Syria's Eastern Ghouta

'Saudization' taking its toll on salesmen

EU leaders to condemn Turkey’s ‘illegal’ actions in Mediterranean

Two Hamas security force members killed in raid on bomb suspect

Exiled Syrian doctors treat refugees in Turkey

Ahed Tamimi reaches plea deal for eight months in jail

UN launching final push to salvage Libya political agreement

Conditions for displaced from Syria's Ghouta 'tragic': UN

Sisi urges Egyptians to vote, denies excluding rivals

Rights Watch says Libya not ready for elections

Saudis revamp school curriculum to combat Muslim Brotherhood

American mother trapped in Syria’s Ghouta calls out Trump

Syria workers say French firm abandoned them to jihadists

Grim Nowruz for Kurds fleeing Afrin

Sarkozy back in custody for second day of questioning

Syrian rebels reach evacuation deal in Eastern Ghouta town

Israel confirms it hit suspected Syrian nuclear reactor in 2007

UN says Turkey security measures 'curtail human rights'

Netanyahu says African migrants threaten Jewish majority

US Senate votes on involvement in Yemen war as Saudi prince visits

What a ‘limited strike’ against Syria’s Assad might mean

Erdogan tells US to stop ‘deceiving’, start helping on Syria

IS controls Damascus district in surprise attack

French ex-president held over Libya financing allegations

NGO says Israeli army violating Palestinian minors’ rights

Human rights chief slams Security Council for inaction on Syria

US warns Turkey over civilians caught in Syria assault

Saudi crown prince keen to cement ties with US

Abbas calls US ambassador to Israel 'son of a dog'

Erdogan vows to expand Syria op to other Kurdish-held areas

Kurdish envoy accuses foreign powers of ignoring Turkish war crimes

Morocco authorities vow to close Jerada's abandoned mines

Israeli soldier sees manslaughter sentence slashed

Turkey insists no plans to remain in Afrin

Cairo voters show unwavering support for native son Sisi

Forum in Jordan explores new teaching techniques

Gaza Strip woes receive renewed attention but no fix is expected

Kurds, Syrian opposition condemn Afrin looting

36 jihadists killed in Egypt’s Sinai

Israel arrests French consulate worker for gun smuggling

Pro-Turkish forces loot Afrin

Israel prepares to demolish Jerusalem attacker's home