First Published: 2017-10-13

The Empire Comes Home
For nearly five decades, Americans have been mesmerized by the governments declarations of war on crime, drugs, and more recently terror. In the name of these perpetual struggles, apathetic citizens have acquiesced in countless assaults on their liberties, argues Danny Sjursen.
Middle East Online

This... thing, [the War on Drugs]

this ain't police work... I mean, you call something a war and pretty soon

everybody gonna be running around acting like warriors... running around on a

damn crusade, storming corners, slapping on cuffs, racking up body counts...

pretty soon, damn near everybody on every corner is your f**king enemy. And

soon the neighborhood that you're supposed to be policing, that's just occupied

territory. Major

"Bunny" Colvin, season three of HBOsThe Wire

I can remember both so well.

2006: my first raid in South Baghdad. 2014: watching on YouTube as a New York

police officer asphyxiated murdered Eric Garner for allegedly selling loose

cigarettes on a Staten Island street corner not five miles from my old

apartment. Both events shocked the conscience.

It was 11 years ago next month: my first patrol of the war and we were still

learning the ropes from the army unit we were replacing. Unit swaps are tricky,

dangerous times. In Army lexicon, theyre known as right-seat-left-seat rides.

Picture a car. When youre learning to drive, you first sit in the passenger

seat and observe. Only then do you occupy the drivers seat. That was Iraq, as

units like ours rotated in and out via an annual revolving door of sorts.

Officers from incoming units like mine were forced to learn the terrain,

identify the key powerbrokers in our assigned area, and sort out the most

effective tactics in the two weeks before the experienced officers departed. It

was a stressful time.

Those transition weeks consisted of daily patrols led by the officers of the

departing unit. My first foray off the FOB (forward operating base) was a night

patrol. The platoon Id tagged along with was going to the house of a suspected

Shiite militia leader. (Back then, we were fighting both Shiite rebels of the

Mahdi Army and Sunni insurgents.) We drove to the outskirts of Baghdad,

surrounded a farmhouse, and knocked on the door. An old woman let us in and a

few soldiers quickly fanned out to search every room. Only women presumably

the suspects mother and sisters were home. Through a translator, my

counterpart, the other lieutenant, loudly asked the old woman where her son was

hiding. Where could we find him? Had he visited the house recently?

Predictably, she claimed to be clueless. After the soldiers vigorously searched

(tossed) a few rooms and found nothing out of the norm, we prepared to leave.

At that point, the lieutenant warned the woman that wed be back just as had

happened several times before until she turned in her own son.

I returned to the FOB with an uneasy feeling. I couldnt understand what it was

that we had just accomplished. How did hassling these women, storming into

their home after dark and making threats, contribute to defeating the Mahdi

Army or earning the loyalty and trust of Iraqi civilians? I was, of course,

brand new to the war, but the incident felt totally counterproductive. Lets

assume the womans sonwasMahdi

Army to the core. So what? Without long-term surveillance or reliable

intelligence placing him at the house, entering the premises that way and

making threats could only solidify whatever aversion the family already had to

the U.S. Army. And what if we had gotten it wrong? What if he was innocent and

wed potentially just helped create a whole new family of insurgents?

Though it wasnt a thought that crossed my mind for years, those women must

have felt like many African-American families living under persistent police

pressure in parts of New York, Baltimore, Chicago, or elsewhere in this

country. Perhaps that sounds outlandish to more affluent whites, but its clear

enough that some impoverished communities of color in this country do indeed

see the police as their enemy. For most military officers, it was similarly

unthinkable that many embattled Iraqis could see all American military

personnel in a negative light. But from that first raid on, I knew one thing

for sure: We were going to have to adjust our perceptions and fast. Not, of

course, that we did.

Years passed. I came home, stayed in the Army, had a kid, divorced, moved a few

more times, remarried, had more kids my Giants even won two Super Bowls.

Suddenly everyone had an iPhone, was on Facebook, or tweeting, or texting

rather than calling. Somehow in those blurred years, Iraq-style police

brutality and violence especially against poor blacks gradually became

front-page news. One case, one shaky YouTube video followed another: Michael

Brown, Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, Philando Castile, and Freddie Gray, just to

start a long list. So many of the clips reminded me of enemy propaganda videos

from Baghdad or helmet-cam shots recorded by our troopers in combat, except

that they came from New York, or Chicago, or San Francisco.

Brutal connections

As in Baghdad, so in

Baltimore. Its connected, you see. Scholars, pundits, politicians, most of us

in fact like our worlds to remain discretely and comfortably separated. Thats

why so few articles, reports, or op-ed columns even think to link police

violence at home to our imperial pursuits abroad or the militarization of the

policing of urban America to our wars across the Greater Middle East and

Africa. I mean, how many profiles of the Black Lives Matter movement even

mention Americas 16-year war on terror across huge swaths of the planet?

Conversely, can you remember a foreign policy piece that cited Ferguson? I

doubt it.

Nonetheless, take a moment to consider the ways in which counterinsurgency

abroad and urban policing at home might, in these years, have come to resemble

each other and might actually be connected phenomena:

The degradations

involved: So often, both counterinsurgency and urban policing

involve countless routine humiliations of a mostly innocent populace. No matter

how weve cloaked the terms partnering, advising, assisting, and so on

the American military has acted like an occupier of Iraq and Afghanistan in

these years. Those thousands of ubiquitous post-invasion U.S. Army foot and

vehicle patrols in both countries tended to highlight the lack of sovereignty

of their peoples. Similarly, as long ago as 1966, author James Baldwin

recognized that New York Citys ghettoes resembled, in his phrase, occupied

territory. In that regard, matters have only worsened since. Just ask the

black community in Baltimore or for that matter Ferguson, Missouri. Its hard

to deny Americas police are becoming progressively more defiant; just last

month St. Louis cops taunted protestors by chanting whose streets?Ourstreets, at a

gathering crowd. Pardon me, but since when has it been okay for police to rule

Americas streets? Arent they there to protect and serve us? Something tells

me the exceedingly libertarian Founding Fathers would be appalled by such


The racial and ethnic

stereotyping. In Baghdad, many U.S. troops called the localshajis,ragheads, or worse


There should be no surprise in that. The frustrations involved in occupation

duty and the fear of death inherent in counterinsurgency campaigns lead

soldiers to stereotype, and sometimes even hate, the populations theyre

(doctrinally) supposed to protect. Ordinary Iraqis or Afghans became the enemy,

an other, worthy only of racial pejoratives and (sometimes) petty cruelties.

Sound familiar? Listen to the private conversations of Americas exasperated

urban police, or the occasionally public insults they throw at the population

theyre paid to protect. I, for one, cant forget the video of an infuriated

white officer taunting Ferguson protestors: Bring it on, you f**king animals!

Or how about a white Staten Island cop caught on the phone bragging to his

girlfriend about how hed framed a young black man or, in his words, fried

another nigger. Dehumanization of the enemy, either at home or abroad, is as

old as empire itself.

The searches:Searches,

searches, and yet more searches. Back in the day in Iraq Im speaking of 2006

and 2007 we didnt exactly need a search warrant to look anywhere we pleased.

The Iraqi courts, police, and judicial system were then barely operational. We

searched houses, shacks, apartments, and high rises for weapons, explosives, or

other contraband. No family guilty or innocent (and they were nearly all

innocent) was safe from the small, daily indignities of a military search.

Back here in the U.S., a similar phenomenon rules, as it has since the war on

drugs era of the 1980s. Its now routine for police SWAT teams to execute

rubber-stamped or no knock search warrants on suspected drug dealers homes

(often only for marijuana stashes) with an aggressiveness most soldiers from

our distant wars would applaud. Then there are the millions of random,

warrantless, body searches on Americas urban, often minority-laden streets.

Take New York, for example, where a discriminatory regime of stop-and-frisk

tactics terrorized blacks and Hispanics for decades. Millions of (mostly)

minority youths were halted and searched by New York police officers who had to

cite only such opaque explanations as furtive movements, or fits relevant

description hardly explicit probable cause to execute such daily

indignities. As numerous studies have shown (and a judicial ruling found), such

stop-and-frisk procedures were discriminatory and likely unconstitutional.

As in my experience in Iraq, so here on the streets of so many urban

neighborhoods of color, anyone, guilty or innocent (mainly innocent) was the

target of such operations. And the connections between war abroad and policing

at home run ever deeper. Consider that in Springfield, Massachusetts, police anti-gang

units learned and applied literal military counterinsurgency doctrine on that

citys streets. In post-9/11 New York City, meanwhile, the NYPD Intelligence

Unit practiced religious profiling and implemented military-style surveillance

to spy on its Muslim residents. Even Americas stalwart Israeli allies no

strangers to domestic counterinsurgency have gotten in on the game. That

countrys Security Forces have been training American cops, despite their long

record of documented human rights abuses. Hows that for coalition warfare and

bilateral cooperation?

The equipment, the

tools of the trade: Who hasnt noticed in recent years that, thanks

in part to a Pentagon program selling weaponry and equipment right off

Americas battlefields, the police on our streets look ever less like kindly

beat cops and ever more like Robocop or the heavily armed and protected troops

of our distant wars? Think of the sheer firepower and armor on the streets of

Ferguson in those photos that shocked and discomforted so many Americans. Or

how about the aftermath of the tragic Boston Marathon Bombing? Watertown,

Massachusetts, surely resembled U.S. Army-occupied Baghdad or Kabul at the

height of their respective troop surges, as the area was locked down under

curfew during the search for the bombing suspects.

Here, at least, the connection is undeniable. The military has sold hundreds of

millions of dollars in excess weapons and equipment armored vehicles, rifles,

camouflage uniforms, and even drones to local police departments, resulting

in a revolving door of self-perpetuating urban militarism. Does Walla Walla,

Washington, really need the very Mine Resistant Ambush-Protected (MRAP) trucks

I drove around Kandahar, Afghanistan? And in case you were worried about the

ability of Madison, Indiana (pop: 12,000), to fight off rocket propelled

grenades thanks to those spiffy new MRAPs, fear not, President Trump recently

overturned Obama-era restrictions on advanced technology transfers to local

police. Let me just add, from my own experiences in Baghdad and Kandahar, that

it has to be a losing proposition to try to be a friendly beat cop and do

community policing from inside an armored vehicle. Even soldiers are taught not

to perform counterinsurgency that way (though we ended up doing so all the



The use of torture has rarely except for several years at the CIAbeen

official policy in these years, but it happened anyway. (See Abu Ghraib, of

course.) It often started small as soldier or police frustration built and

the usual minor torments of the locals morphed into outright abuse. The same

process seems underway here in the U.S. as well, which was why, as a 34-year

old New Yorker, when I first saw the photos at Abu Ghraib, I flashed back to the

way, in 1997, the police sodomized Abner Louima, a Haitian immigrant, in my own

hometown. Younger folks might consider the far more recent case in Baltimore of

Freddie Gray, brutally and undeservedly handcuffed, his pleas ignored, and then

driven in the back of a police van to his death. Furthermore, we now know about

two decades worth of systematic torture of more than 100 black men by the

Chicago police in order to solicit (often false) confessions.

Unwinnable wars: at

home and abroad

For nearly five decades,

Americans have been mesmerized by the governments declarations of war on

crime, drugs, and more recently terror. In the name of these perpetual

struggles, apathetic citizens have acquiesced in countless assaults on their

liberties. Think warrantless wiretapping, the Patriot Act, and the use of a

drone to execute an (admittedly deplorable) American citizen without due

process. The First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments who needs them anyway? None

of these onslaughts against the supposedly sacred Bill of Rights have ended

terror attacks, prevented a raging opioid epidemic, staunched Chicagos record

murder rate, or thwarted Americas ubiquitous mass shootings, of which the Las

Vegas tragedy is only the latest and most horrific example. The wars on drugs,

crime, and terror theyre all unwinnable and tear at the core of American

society. In our apathy, we are all complicit.

Like so much else in our contemporary politics, Americans divide, like

clockwork, into opposing camps over police brutality, foreign wars, and

Americas original sin: racism. All too often in these debates, arguments

arent rational but emotional as people feel their way to intractable opinions.

Its become a cultural matter, transcending traditional policy debates. Want to

start a sure argument with your dad? Bring up police brutality. I promise you

its foolproof.

So heres a final link between our endless war on terror and rising

militarization on what is no longer called the home front: Theres a striking

overlap between those who instinctively give the increasingly militarized

police of that homeland the benefit of the doubt and those who viscerally

support our wars across the Greater Middle East and Africa.

It may be something of a clich that distant wars have a way of coming home,

but that doesnt make it any less true. Policing today is being Baghdadified in

the United States. Over the last 40 years, as Washington struggled to maintain

its global military influence, the nations domestic police have progressively

shifted to military-style patrol, search, and surveillance tactics, while

measuring success through statistical models familiar to any Pentagon staff


Please understand this: For me when it comes to the police, its nothing

personal. A couple of my uncles were New York City cops. Nearly half my family

has served or still serves in the New York Fire Department. Im from

blue-collar, civil service stock. Good guys, all. But experience tells me that

they arent likely to see the connections Im making between whats happening

here and whats been happening in our distant war zones or agree with my

conclusions about them. In a similar fashion, few of my peers in the military

officer corps are likely to agree, or even recognize, the parallels Ive drawn.

Of course, these days when you talk about the military and the police, youre

often talking about the very same people, since veterans from our wars are now

making their way into police forces across the country, especially the highly

militarized SWAT teams proliferating nationwide that use the sorts of

smash-and-search tactics perfected abroad in recent years. While less than 6%

of Americans are vets, some 19% of law-enforcement personnel have served in the

U.S. military. In many ways its a natural fit, as former soldiers seamlessly

slide into police life and pick up the very weaponry they once used in

Afghanistan, Iraq, or elsewhere.

The widespread perpetuation of uneven policing and criminal (in)justice can be

empirically shown. Consider the numerous critical Justice Department

investigations of major American cities. But what concerns me in all of this is

a simple enough question: What happens to the republic when the militarism that

is part and parcel of our now more or less permanent state of war abroad takes

over ever more of the prevailing culture of policing at home?

And heres the inconvenient truth: Despite numerous instances of brutality and

murder perpetrated by the U.S. military personnel overseas think Haditha (the

infamous retaliatory massacre of Iraqi civilians by U.S. Marines), Panjwai

(where a U.S. Army Sergeant left his base and methodically executed nearby

Afghan villagers), and of course Abu Ghraib in my experience, our army is

often stricter about interactions with foreign civilians than many local

American police forces are when it comes to communities of color. After all, if

one ofmymen

strangled an Iraqi to death for breaking a minor civil law (as happened to Eric

Garner), you can bet that the soldier, his sergeant, and I would have been

disciplined, even if, as is so often the case, such accountability never

reached the senior-officer level.

Ultimately, the irony is this: Poor Eric Garner at least if he had run into

my platoon would have been safer in Baghdad than on that street corner in New

York. Either way, he and so many others should perhaps count as domestic

casualties of my generations forever war.

Whats global is local. And vice versa. American society is embracing its inner

empire. Eventually, its long reach may come for us all.

Major Danny Sjursen writes

regularly forTomDispatch.

He is a U.S. Army strategist and former history instructor at West Point. He

served tours with reconnaissance units in Iraq and Afghanistan. He has written

a memoir and critical analysis of the Iraq War,Ghost Riders

of Baghdad: Soldiers, Civilians, and the Myth of the Surge.He lives with his wife and four

sons in Lawrence, Kansas. Follow him on Twitter at @SkepticalVet.


Copyright 2017 Danny Sjursen


Sarkozy says life ‘living hell’ since corruption allegations

Hezbollah leader says debt threatens Lebanon disaster

Turkey’s largest media group to be sold to Erdogan ally

Rebels to evacuate Syria's Eastern Ghouta

'Saudization' taking its toll on salesmen

EU leaders to condemn Turkey’s ‘illegal’ actions in Mediterranean

Two Hamas security force members killed in raid on bomb suspect

Exiled Syrian doctors treat refugees in Turkey

Ahed Tamimi reaches plea deal for eight months in jail

UN launching final push to salvage Libya political agreement

Conditions for displaced from Syria's Ghouta 'tragic': UN

Sisi urges Egyptians to vote, denies excluding rivals

Rights Watch says Libya not ready for elections

Saudis revamp school curriculum to combat Muslim Brotherhood

American mother trapped in Syria’s Ghouta calls out Trump

Syria workers say French firm abandoned them to jihadists

Grim Nowruz for Kurds fleeing Afrin

Sarkozy back in custody for second day of questioning

Syrian rebels reach evacuation deal in Eastern Ghouta town

Israel confirms it hit suspected Syrian nuclear reactor in 2007

UN says Turkey security measures 'curtail human rights'

Netanyahu says African migrants threaten Jewish majority

US Senate votes on involvement in Yemen war as Saudi prince visits

What a ‘limited strike’ against Syria’s Assad might mean

Erdogan tells US to stop ‘deceiving’, start helping on Syria

IS controls Damascus district in surprise attack

French ex-president held over Libya financing allegations

NGO says Israeli army violating Palestinian minors’ rights

Human rights chief slams Security Council for inaction on Syria

US warns Turkey over civilians caught in Syria assault

Saudi crown prince keen to cement ties with US

Abbas calls US ambassador to Israel 'son of a dog'

Erdogan vows to expand Syria op to other Kurdish-held areas

Kurdish envoy accuses foreign powers of ignoring Turkish war crimes

Morocco authorities vow to close Jerada's abandoned mines

Israeli soldier sees manslaughter sentence slashed

Turkey insists no plans to remain in Afrin

Cairo voters show unwavering support for native son Sisi

Forum in Jordan explores new teaching techniques

Gaza Strip woes receive renewed attention but no fix is expected

Kurds, Syrian opposition condemn Afrin looting

36 jihadists killed in Egypt’s Sinai

Israel arrests French consulate worker for gun smuggling

Pro-Turkish forces loot Afrin

Israel prepares to demolish Jerusalem attacker's home