First Published: 2017-11-13

Israel Lobby is Slowly Being Dragged into the Light
Conservative Friends of Israel chief has recruited four-fifths of Conservative MPs, and almost every government minister, to a group whose explicit goal is to advance Israeli interests in Britain, points out Jonathan Cook.
Middle East Online

The scandal surrounding Priti Patel, who was forced to resign as Britains international aid minister last week after secret meetings with Israeli officials during a family holiday, offers a small, opaque window on the UKs powerful Israel lobby.

Patels off-the-books meetings with 12 Israelis, including prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, were organised by a British lobbyist in violation of government rules requiring careful documentation of official meetings. That is to prevent conflicts of interest and illicit lobbying by foreign powers.

Government protocol was flouted again when Patel headed to the Golan Heights, occupied Syrian territory, escorted by the Israeli army. There she was shown an Israeli military field hospital that patches up Syrians, including Al Qaeda-affiliated fighters, wounded in Syrias civil war.

Afterwards, Patel pressed for the Israeli army, one of the most powerful in the world, to receive a chunk of Britains overseas aid. Meanwhile, she has sought to cut aid to the Palestinians, including to vital projects in Gaza. A clue as to how she reached such absurd humanitarian priorities is provided in the figure of Stuart Polak, mentor on her Israel holiday.

The honorary president of Conservative Friends of Israel, Lord Polak has recruited four-fifths of Conservative MPs, and almost every government minister, to a group whose explicit goal is to advance Israeli interests in Britain. The prime minister, Theresa May, is regarded as one of Israels most fervent supporters in Europe.

That should be a cause for public indignation no other foreign state enjoys such unabashed, high-level political support.

Another window on Israels meddling opened briefly last week. The BBCs political editor, Laura Kuenssberg, took to Twitter to relay a damning comment from an unnamed senior member of Patels party. In a clear reference to Israel, the source observed: The entire apparatus has turned a blind eye to a corrupt relationship that allows a country to buy access.

A short time later, presumably under pressure, Kuenssberg deleted the tweet. The BBC has not reported the comment elsewhere and the senior Conservative has not dared go public. Such, it seems, is the intimidating and corrupting influence of the lobby.

More than a decade ago, two leading American academics wrote a study of the Israel lobbys role in the United States, Israels chief patron for half a century. It was a sign of the lobbys influence that John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt could not find a publisher at home. They had to turn to a British journal instead.

The Israel lobbys strength in western capitals has depended precisely on its ability to remain out of view. Simply to talk about the lobby risks being accused of perpetuating anti-Semitic tropes of Jewish cabals.

But Mearsheimer and Walt described a type of pressure group familiar in the US and increasingly in European capitals. Everyone from Cuba to health insurers and arms manufacturers operate aggressive lobbyists in Washington to secure their interests.

What is special about the Israel lobby in the US an amalgam of hawkish Jewish leadership organisations and messianic Christian evangelicals is the fear it exploits to silence critics. No one wants to be labelled an anti-Semite.

Rarely identified or held to account, the lobby has entrenched its power.

That is what Britains heir to the throne, Prince Charles, was talking about three decades ago even if he misidentified it as a Jewish rather Israel lobby in a forgotten letter found in the public archives and publicised at the weekend.

Surely some US president has to have the courage to stand up and take on the Jewish lobby in the US? I must be naive, I suppose! he wrote to a family friend in 1986.

Today, as recent events illustrate, the lobby is struggling to stay in the shadows. Social media and Palestinians with camera phones have exposed a global audience to systematic abuses by the Israeli army the western media largely ignored. For the first time, Israel supporters sound evasive and dissembling.

Meanwhile, Netanyahus strident efforts in the US Congress through 2014 and 2015 to prevent a nuclear accord with Iran dragged the lobby even farther into the light.

The Israel lobbys dirty tricks in the UK were exposed earlier this year too. An Al Jazeera TV documentary showed Conservative party officials colluding with the Israeli embassy to take down Alan Duncan, a foreign office minister who supports the Palestinian cause.

It is noteworthy that Ms Patels downfall came about because of social media. Israeli officials like police minister Gilad Erdan were so unused to scrutiny or accountability themselves that they happily tweeted photos with Patel. Erdan is a key player in the lobby, running a smear unit to target overseas critics of Israel.

We may never know why Patel so grossly flouted ministerial rules or what she quietly promised in those meetings in Israel. Colleagues have hinted that, in a pattern familiar from US politics, she hoped to win over the lobby and its wealthy donors for a future leadership bid.

There is no way to know, given the lobbys penchant for secrecy, whether Patel simply proved less adept at treading a path marked out by former Conservative and Labour party leadership hopefuls. But it is also possible that the lobby is discovering changes to the political and cultural environment are making its work much harder.

There is growing hysteria about foreign interference in US and European politics. Is it not time for western states to show as much concern about the malign influence of Israels lobbyists as they do about Russian hackers?

A version of this article first appeared in the National, Abu Dhabi.

Jonathan Cook won the Martha Gellhorn Special Prize for Journalism. His latest books are Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the Middle East (Pluto Press) and Disappearing Palestine: Israels Experiments in Human Despair (Zed Books). His website is


Thousands flee Syria's Ghouta after month-long bombardment

Thirty years on, Kurds remember Halabja massacre

Crown prince says if Iran gets nuclear bomb, so will Saudi Arabia

No room for debate in Egyptian elections

Kuwaitis flock to get hands on rare ‘desert truffle’

Tearful reunions, uncertain fates for Syrians fleeing Ghouta

Iran deal signatories meet as Trump deadline looms

Air India says will fly over Saudi airspace to Tel Aviv

UN chief calls for end to Lebanese 'meddling' in Syria

Turkey seeks jail for journalists opposing government

UN says civilians trapped, used as 'human shields' in Afrin

Iran, Russia, Turkey hold Syria talks in Astana

Civilians killed in Turkish fire on Syria's Afrin

US Defense Secretary says Iran 'mucking around' in Iraq elections

Israel closes migrant detention centre in expulsion plan

UN security council says Yemen conditions 'devastating' for civilians

UNRWA chief says agency needs urgent funds by summer

Turkey to host Syria summit on April 4 with Russia, Iran

Turkey journalists protest for colleague after 500 days in prison

UN says Syria regime forces using rape as wide-scale weapon

Turkey expects to take Afrin centre in ‘very short time’

Israel attacks Hamas posts in Gaza

Egypt expects tourism upsurge ahead of vote

Syrian lawyer that negotiated Raqa IS deal found dead

Convoy of food aid enters Syria’s Ghouta

Qatar’s BeIN media slams Egypt court fine

Syrian war enters eighth year

Qatar spends 3 billion on military helicopters

Hamas widens probe into bomb attack against Palestinian PM

Russian FM claims Syria rebels planning to ‘stage’ chemical attack

Bodies of women killed in private jet crash return to Turkey

Turkey ramps up assault on Syria's Afrin

Saudi Arabia fast-tracking nuclear energy programme

Israeli government avoids snap polls but Netanyahu's fate uncertain

UN Palestinian agency faces cash crisis

Iraq’s Halabja still poisoned by gas attack thirty years on

Second day of medical evacuations begins in Syria's Ghouta

EU unlocks second tranche in Turkey migrant deal

Turkey jails man for life for Syrian activist murders

Auditors lament ‘limited effect’ of EU’s Turkey membership funding

ARC development aims to boost Aqaba’s touristic appeal

Tillerson sacking could sound death knell for Iran nuclear deal

Baghdad ends air blockade of Kurdish region

Palestinian PM escapes explosion on rare Gaza visit

Turkish forces 'surround' Afrin city