First Published: 2018-01-16

European leaders response to Iran protests raises questions
EU foreign affairs chief Federica Mogherini took six days to comment on the protests before issuing a bland statement.
Middle East Online

By Mahmud el-Shafey - LONDON

A woman chants slogans during a protest against the visit of Irans Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif outside the European Union Council in Brussels

As Iranians protested the countrys sputtering economy, rampant corruption and rising food and fuel prices, European leaders faced a dilemma on how to respond.

They, along with the European Union itself, chose caution and restraint, taking into consideration the huge economic deals they have at stake with Tehran. European officials were denounced by critics who accused them of being more concerned with preserving the Iran nuclear deal than with condemning Tehrans crackdown against protesters.

There were more than 20 deaths and 1,000 arrests during the nationwide protests, which erupted in Mashhad, Irans second-largest city, on December 28.

EU foreign affairs chief Federica Mogherini took six days to comment on the protests before issuing a bland statement. In the spirit of openness and respect that is at the root of our relationship, we expect all concerned to refrain from violence and to guarantee freedom of expression, she said.

UK Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson issued a single Tweet, saying only that he was watching events with concern. German Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel also responded cautiously, saying: We appeal to the Iranian government to respect the rights of the demonstrators to assemble and to peacefully raise their voices.

These utterings from the heavyweights in EU foreign policy circles can be seen as accurately reflecting the dilemma EU members are in due to the current disturbances in Iran, Magnus Norell, an adjunct scholar at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, said in a posting on the groups website.

Writing for the institutes Fikra Forum, an Arabic-English online community that aims to connect Arab reformers with US policymakers, Norell said the European Union was pussyfooting on Iran.

Having invested a considerate amount of diplomatic capital in the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) two years ago and since then selling goods to Iran worth $10 billion in 2016 alone, as well as trying to get over the shock of having Donald Trump as the president upsetting policy conventions across the globe, the last thing the EU needs now is another potential disruption in their backyard in the Middle East, he added.

The foreign ministers of Iran, France, Germany and the United Kingdom met in Brussels on January 11, focusing on JCPOA amid signs that US President Donald Trump would not recertify the deal.

The protests in Iran were not explicitly mentioned, with Mogherini saying: Unity is essential to preserve a deal that is working, that is making the world safer, that is preventing a nuclear arms race in the region.

Unsurprisingly, Trump has been outspoken in his criticism of the Iran government and gave the strongest indication that he would choose not to recertify the Iran nuclear deal.

Iran is failing at every level despite the terrible deal made with them by the Obama administration. The great Iranian people have been repressed for many years. They are hungry for food & for freedom. Along with human rights, the wealth of Iran is being looted. TIME FOR CHANGE! Trump tweeted January 1.

US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson not only spoke out forcefully in support of the protests and criticised Europes relative silence on the issue.

Were disappointed that the European Union has not taken a more definitive stance in supporting those voices in the country that are calling for reform, he said.

Some analysts also criticised Europes lack of response to the protests. Europes response to the regimes violent suppression of protests after the stolen elections of 2009 was firm. The EU should send the same message today, said US journalist Eli Lake in an opinion piece carried by Bloomberg News.

In Britain, the main opposition Labour Party faced major criticism for its silence on the issue. While Johnsons statement was criticised as perfunctory, opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn, who has made numerous paid appearances on Irans state-owned Press TV, remained silent.

Seeking to defend Corbyn, UK Shadow Foreign Secretary Emily Thornberry argued for extreme caution on Iran.

Our approach now is one of extreme caution when it comes to Iran and a recognition that the society in Iran is an immensely complex one and seemingly contradictory, she told the BBCs Political Thinking podcast.

So we take a cautious approach in Iran and we dont want to leap to judgment and say: Well, we dont like the regime in Iran, these people are against it, they must be the guy in white hats.

However, this is a policy that Labour has failed to abide by on other complex issues in the Middle East, from criticising the governments sanction of arms to Saudi Arabia to issues surrounding human rights abuse in Egypt and Bahrain.

Despite criticisms, analysts said outspoken Western condemnation of the Iranian regime and outpourings of support for the protesters could backfire.

The fact that we are actually making statements that we think are in favour of the Iranian people, they are hurting them more than anything, Iranian-American analyst Holly Dagres told CNN.

Tehran has sought to use foreign criticism of it and statements supporting the protesters as evidence that outside forces are behind the recent unrest.

The enemy is waiting for an opportunity, for a flaw, through which they can enter. Look at these events over the last few days. All those who are against the Islamic Republic they have all joined forces to create problems for the Islamic Republic, Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said.

Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif tweeted that infiltrators would not be allowed to sabotage Iran through violence and destruction.

With the European Union choosing to focus on saving the JCPOA and Trump choosing to reluctantly extend the nuclear deal, the Iranians who risked their lives to take to the streets found their protests brushed aside by Europes leaders.

Mahmud el-Shafey is an Arab Weekly correspondent in London.

This article was originally published in The Arab Weekly.


Pro-Turkish forces loot Afrin

Israel arrests French consulate worker for gun smuggling

Sudan leader backs Sisi election bid

Morocco authorities vow to close Jerada's abandoned mines

Iraqis flock to flea market for relics of bygone era

Erdogan vows to expand Syria op to other Kurdish-held areas

Kurdish envoy accuses foreign powers of ignoring Turkish war crimes

Israeli soldier sees manslaughter sentence slashed

Turkey insists no plans to remain in Afrin

Cairo voters show unwavering support for native son Sisi

Forum in Jordan explores new teaching techniques

Gaza Strip woes receive renewed attention but no fix is expected

Kurds, Syrian opposition condemn Afrin looting

36 jihadists killed in Egypt’s Sinai

Israel prepares to demolish Jerusalem attacker's home

Saudi crown prince says his country to seek nuclear bomb if Iran does

Arab women artists in diaspora focus on identity and loss

Tunisia’s Central Bank targets inflation but may hurt growth prospects

Libya’s health system reflects a larger humanitarian crisis

Israel blasts Gaza underground tunnel

Abu Dhabi awards France's Total stakes in oil concessions

Erdogan says Afrin city centre under ‘total’ control

Egypt tries to contain Sudan but challenges, suspicions remain

US defence secretary presses Oman on Iran weapons smuggling

Syrian regime retakes two towns from Ghouta rebels

Hamas shutters mobile firm after Gaza attack on PM

Israel punishes family members of West Bank attacker

Syria opposition says UN 'failed to prevent' Assad 'crimes'

UK tries to soothe Egyptian anger over mob attack death

Hundreds of thousands flee in dual Syria assaults

Turkish Cypriots vow to stand firm in gas dispute

Intensifying assaults in Syria spark dual evacuations

Tearful reunions, uncertain fates for Syrians fleeing Ghouta

Iran deal signatories meet as Trump deadline looms

Thirty years on, Kurds remember Halabja massacre

Air India says will fly over Saudi airspace to Tel Aviv

UN chief calls for end to Lebanese 'meddling' in Syria

Turkey seeks jail for journalists opposing government

UN says civilians trapped, used as 'human shields' in Afrin

Iran, Russia, Turkey hold Syria talks in Astana

Civilians killed in Turkish fire on Syria's Afrin

US Defense Secretary says Iran 'mucking around' in Iraq elections

No room for debate in Egyptian elections

Thousands flee Syria's Ghouta after month-long bombardment

Israel closes migrant detention centre in expulsion plan